Musky caught by an angler on a northern lakePhoto: Musky caught by an angler on a northern lake

Updated: Thursday, September 24, 2026 · Next update: Thursday, October 1, 2026

This Thousand Islands NY fishing report covers late September, the start of fall prime time on the St. Lawrence River, one of the best fall fisheries in North America. Muskie are the lead target, and fall is the best time to catch a big one, so hunters put in long hours. Smallmouth bass stack on deep structure and northern pike feed on the weed edges. The condition to plan around is cooling water in the low 60s, which sets off the fall feeding push.

What’s Hitting

Muskie are the top target. Smallmouth bass stack on deep structure, with quality fish over four pounds in the mix. Northern pike feed along the weed edges, and walleye and yellow perch are also active.

YOUR 90-SECOND FRIDAY FISHING PLAN

Know what is worth fishing this weekend.

Get the best of Thursday's reports from 40 destinations, plus timely tactics and one useful gear read, in a short Friday email.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Where to Find Them

Muskie use the shoals, weed edges and drop-offs throughout the Thousand Islands. These ambush predators favor edges where weed meets open water or a shoal falls into the channel, giving them cover close to passing baitfish.

Target smallmouth on the deep rock piles and shoals in 20 to 40 feet of water. Pike work the weed edges in the bays, and walleye sit on the deeper structure.

Tides & Conditions

There are no tides on the St. Lawrence, but current matters. Water temperatures in the low 60s and falling trigger the fall feeding push. Windy days are good for muskie but make for challenging conditions on the big water, so pick your areas with the wind in mind.

Tackle & Tactics

  • Muskie: troll large crankbaits, or cast bucktails, jerkbaits and swimbaits. Finish every cast with a figure-8.
  • Smallmouth: a drop-shot rig, tube jig or jigging spoon on deep structure; a slow-drifting drop-shot with a goby-colored bait is the most consistent producer on the deep shoals.
  • Pike: spinnerbaits, spoons or swimbaits along the weed edges.
  • Use a heavy leader for muskie and pike, since both have teeth that cut light line.

Plan on long days and short bursts of action for muskie. Most fish this time of year come in the last hour of light or when a front pushes through, so stay on your best spots when the weather changes rather than running around.

Local Intel This Week

Clayton and Alexandria Bay are the main towns, and both have public boat launches and many fishing guides. Cedar Point State Park near Clayton and Keewaydin State Park at Alexandria Bay offer more access, and Tibbetts Point marks the head of the river at Cape Vincent. Launch close to the shoals you plan to fish to save time on short fall days. The St. Lawrence is a border water, so if you cross into Canadian waters you also need Ontario licenses and rules. Check current state and federal regulations and seasons before keeping fish.

This Week’s Tip

Muskie often follow lures to the boat without striking. Finish every cast with a figure-8 at the side of the boat; the sudden change in direction and speed is often what triggers the strike.


Want the current report each week? Subscribe free to Fishing.Digital for timely fishing reports, seasonal tactics and new gear guides.

Planning a trip to Thousand Islands NY?

This report tells you what happened. ReelAI tells you what to do about it — a briefing for your date, your target species and how you're fishing, built from our reports plus live NOAA and USGS data.

Powered by ReelAI — fishing.digital's intelligence layer. Answers are generated from fishing.digital reports and public NOAA, NWS and USGS data, and may be incomplete or out of date. Regulations and marine safety information are summaries only; always confirm with the responsible authority before you fish.

Build a full ReelAI Trip Report →

By Dennis Suler

Dennis Suler is a career outdoors writer and member of the Outdoor Writers Association of America (OWAA). He reports on inshore and offshore fishing across 40 U.S. destinations for fishing.digital.