Musky caught by an angler on a northern lakePhoto: Musky caught by an angler on a northern lake

Updated: Thursday, September 10, 2026 · Next update: Thursday, September 17, 2026

This Thousand Islands NY fishing report covers mid-September, when the first cool nights start to turn the St. Lawrence on. Muskie are the lead target, moving onto the shoals and weed edges as the water cools,. Smallmouth feed hard on the current breaks and walleye are steady on the deep edges at dusk. The main condition to plan around is the west to northwest wind that roughs up the open river.

What’s Hitting

Muskie fishing picks up on the shoals and weed edges from Clayton through Alexandria Bay and the Chippewa Bay area, with fish showing on trolling passes and following on the casting spots. The best water is the deeper shoals in 20 to 40 feet where the bait is stacked. Smallmouth from 2 to 5 pounds sit on the shoals and current breaks in 15 to 30 feet, feeding on gobies and crayfish. Walleye use the deep edges and channel drop-offs at dusk, with Chippewa Bay and the Cape Vincent water the top areas. Northern pike work the weed edges in the bays.

YOUR 90-SECOND FRIDAY FISHING PLAN

Know what is worth fishing this weekend.

Get the best of Thursday's reports from 40 destinations, plus timely tactics and one useful gear read, in a short Friday email.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Largemouth use the weeds in the back bays, and perch fishing on the deep flats is good.

Where to Find Them

For muskie, focus on the 40-Acre Shoal area, the Grenadier Island shoals and the Chippewa Bay edges. Troll the deeper edges in 20 to 40 feet and cast the weed edges in the mornings and evenings. Target smallmouth on the shoals and current breaks around the islands and on the rock points near Cape Vincent. Fish walleye on the channel edges and deep drop-offs from Chippewa Bay to Cape Vincent at dusk. Pike use bay weed edges and marinas.

Tides & Conditions

The new moon this weekend means no tides on the river, but the dark nights and cooling water push the bait and the predators onto the shoals. Expect west to northwest winds at 10 to 15 with some rough days on the open river. Water temps sit in the upper 60s, clarity is good on the main river and fair in the bays, and the current runs at normal seasonal flows.

Tackle & Tactics

  • Muskie: troll big crankbaits and jerkbaits on the deep shoal edges at 3 to 4 miles per hour, or cast big bucktails, jerkbaits and rubber baits on the weed edges. Use a heavy rod, 80 to 100-pound braid and a fluorocarbon or wire leader, and bring a big net and release tools.
  • Smallmouth: a drop-shot rig, a tube or a goby-imitating plastic on the shoals.
  • Walleye: crankbaits trolled on the deep edges and jigs tipped with a minnow at dusk.
  • Pike: spinnerbaits and jerkbaits on the weeds.

Local Intel This Week

The Clayton village ramp and the French Creek ramp serve the upper river, the Alexandria Bay public ramp and the Keewaydin State Park ramp cover the middle islands, and the Cape Vincent village ramp is the main access to the head of the river. The Chippewa Bay ramp serves the lower end. Muskie carry a strong release ethic on the river, and a Canadian license is required for any water on the Ontario side. Check current state and federal regulations and seasons before keeping fish.

This Week’s Tip

Muskie on the deep shoals in September follow the bait rather than sitting on the structure. Troll the edge of the shoal where the depth drops from 20 to 40 feet and watch your electronics for bait balls. When you mark bait, make repeated passes along that edge at different depths. The fish are where the bait is, and the bait moves.


Want the current report each week? Subscribe free to Fishing.Digital for timely fishing reports, seasonal tactics and new gear guides.

Planning a trip to Thousand Islands NY?

This report tells you what happened. ReelAI tells you what to do about it — a briefing for your date, your target species and how you're fishing, built from our reports plus live NOAA and USGS data.

Powered by ReelAI — fishing.digital's intelligence layer. Answers are generated from fishing.digital reports and public NOAA, NWS and USGS data, and may be incomplete or out of date. Regulations and marine safety information are summaries only; always confirm with the responsible authority before you fish.

Build a full ReelAI Trip Report →

By Dennis Suler

Dennis Suler is a career outdoors writer and member of the Outdoor Writers Association of America (OWAA). He reports on inshore and offshore fishing across 40 U.S. destinations for fishing.digital.